How to Choose the Best Roofing Contractor

Summer’s ending and winter will be here before you know it. If you’ve been putting off a project, now is the time to finish it. Whether you’re finally replacing that old roof, leaky roof or fixing up storm damage, one thing’s for sure: the Frederick roofing contractor you choose makes all the difference. 

Three,dormers,and,two,chimneys

But here’s the thing; everyone seems to be booking roofers this time of the year, and (let’s be real) not all contractors are reliable. Some don’t show up. Others cut corners. A few just stop responding altogether. We’ve heard it all.

So how do you find someone dependable, someone who shows up, does solid work, and doesn’t leave you hanging? Let’s walk through it.

At Topper Roofing, we’ve been serving homeowners and builders across the Mid-Atlantic for more than 30 years. We’ve seen what happens when a job is rushed, and we’ve seen what happens when it’s done right. Here’s a straightforward guide to help you choose the right roofer for your summer project.

1. Start With Experience and Reputation

These days, it’s easy for anyone to build a website and say they’re a roofer. What you really want is someone with a track record, local reviews, referrals, and proof of past work.

It’s worth asking neighbors for recommendations and browsing some before-and-after photos. If a roofer’s confident in their work, they’ll happily share them. 

At Topper Roofing, we’ve built our reputation over decades. We’re proud to be a Preferred Contractor for Owens Corning, which means we meet high standards for professionalism, reliability, and craftsmanship.

2. Check Licensing, Insurance, and Certifications

If a contractor can’t provide proof of licensing and insurance, walk away. These aren’t just nice-to-haves, you’ll want these in place in case anything unexpected happens during the job.

Also, check for certifications from major manufacturers (like Owens Corning or Tamko). These show that the contractor’s been trained to install their products properly and that you’re eligible for stronger warranties.

Want to go deeper? Angi has a great checklist for hiring roofing contractors that’s worth a skim.

3. Check Reviews, But Read Between the Lines

Reviews are useful, but don’t take them at face value. Is the feedback all fluff, or are people talking about real things: like communication, timeliness, or how the cleanup went?

One glowing five-star review doesn’t tell you much. But if a dozen customers mention how the crew arrived on time, explained everything clearly, and left their yard spotless? Those are the details that really tell you what working with them is like.

4. Ask About Materials and Warranties

Some cheaper roofs might look fine, until a strong storm hits.

Ask what materials your contractor uses. A solid roofer will be transparent about brands, warranties, and options. Be cautious if someone quotes you a deal that seems way too good. That usually means they’re skimping somewhere, and it often comes back to bite you.

We work with Owens Corning and other leading brands, so you get top-tier materials backed by manufacturer warranties that actually hold up.

5. Get a Written Estimate And Compare

Get at least three detailed estimates, and make sure each one spells out materials, labor, timeline, and payment terms.

It might be tempting to go with the cheapest, but it may be because they’re using off-brand shingles, or rushing the job. Another might be slightly higher but offer better communication, better materials, and a longer-lasting result.

We believe in being upfront, our quotes include everything, no hidden costs.

6. Pay Attention to How They Communicate

This is a big one. If a contractor takes days to reply or is vague in their answers before the job starts, expect that to continue once the work begins.

They should be easy to reach, explain what’s happening, and keep you updated throughout. Roofing isn’t a small job, you shouldn’t have to guess what’s going on.

7. Get Everything in Writing

Verbal estimates might seem fine, until there’s a disagreement later. Always get a full written contract, and read it. It should include everything: labor, materials, timelines, payment schedule, warranties, the whole deal.

If something feels vague or fuzzy, ask. A trustworthy contractor won’t take offense, they’ll walk you through it.

We do this all the time at Topper Roofing. It’s how we build trust, and avoid surprises later.

8. Stick With Local Pros

A local roofer knows the climate, the building codes, and the styles in your neighborhood. If you ever need to follow up, you’ll have an easier time getting help.

We’ve been part of the Mid-Atlantic community since day one. We know what kind of roofs work best here, and we treat every home like it’s our own.

Ready to Start Your Roofing Project?

If you’ve got a roofing project planned before winter hits, don’t leave it to chance. Work with a contractor who shows up, does the job right, and stands behind their work. Contact us today to get a quote or learn more about our work at Topper Roofing.

Keep reading…

Roofing Considerations for Harsh Winter Storms in Maryland

A Seasonal Guide to Protect Your Home from Snow, Ice, and Freeze-Thaw Damage Maryland winters are unpredictable. One day it’s mild and sunny, the next, a mix of snow, sleet, and ice is hitting your roof from all sides. For Frederick homeowners and surrounding...

Understanding Your Roof’s Warranty: What Homeowners Should Know

When it comes to your house, the roof is one of the largest investments you will ever make. But surprisingly, very few homeowners have a full understanding of what their roof warranty really covers - or how to compare one bid against another. If you're looking into...

How Gutters & Downspouts Affect Your Roof’s Longevity

For most homeowners, gutters and downspouts are the last thing on their mind when they think about roof care—shingles and flashing usually get all the attention. But gutters and downspouts play a critical role in protecting your roof and your entire home from water...

Request Your Free Estimate Today

Don’t let roofing or siding issues wait. Contact Topper Roofing for a free estimate today!

Topper Construction, Inc. BBB Business Review